Seven Days in MayPacifists and authoritarians apart, it is agreed all across the American political spectrum that some defiance of law can be justified, even in a democracy, in rejection of injustice or with the aim of securing justice.
The defining division between left and right as regards what are the demands of justice is in the matter of property rights.
But key differences as regards what one may do about injustice turn on differences concerning other political values, chief among them being democracy.
And the fact is that a signficant portion of the everyday right, the ordinary right, the normal right such as we find it, for example, dominating the Republican Party sets little or no value on democracy
per se and is now and has historically been willing to limit it, frustrate it, and even abandon it to protect what they see as justice in the matter of property rights.
That is to say, the dominant strands of the ordinary right of America are part of the further right, or the extreme right, and teach every day in their propaganda an essentially subversive message about just when and why, for example, a military coup against our own government might be legitimate.
In contrast, and just because almost everybody on the left sets some store by democracy, there are very few on the left would would be willing to abandon it to advance or protect what the left see as justice in this same area.
That is to say, the further or extreme left are vastly outnumbered by the democratic left who dominate the Democratic Party and the outlook expressed by almost all the propaganda of the left in America.
Actually, this was very likely true even in the depths of the Cold War when the right was so powerful in America that it could create a red scare, causing Americans to look under their beds in terror lest Communists overthrow our government and take over the country, or at least sell it out to the Russians who would themselves destroy our democracy, our freedom, and our American Way of Life.
Not everybody was taken in by the lie.
A good many thought the real danger was on the right.
Hence the film, Seven Days in May.
The threat of Communism is gone, now, of course.
But the danger on the right is not.
Those hillbilly conservatives I spoke with a few weeks ago were typical of many.
They are the real menace.
They and the entire conservative movement from which they have learned their political values.
PS.
It is noteworthy that the willingness of the right to overthrow democracy in order to protect property has always been very clearly demonstrated in American foreign policy, especially but not only in Latin America.
It is also worth noticing that Democrats have frequently been divided by such right-wing interventions.
Thus the picture is clouded as to what lessons we could draw about their respective attitudes toward any right-wing coup in our own country.
Labels: a dime's worth of difference, Class war, The Further Left, The Further Right